The October 2026 report for Boise County single-family homes from Intermountain MLS opens with 21 homes sold in October, a median price of $582,125 and a median that slipped 4.96% from October 2025. A few lines lower, existing homes alone sold 12 times that month at a $479,500 median, down 22.03% from a year earlier.
If you are comparing cabin markets and Garden Valley is on your list, that 22% drop says little about Garden Valley. The county report describes a mix of homes that is moving away from what Garden Valley sells, and Garden Valley's own sales come in such small numbers that one month's median says more about which houses closed than about where prices are headed.
Two different markets in one county report
Intermountain MLS splits Boise County into three mountain areas: Horseshoe Bend, Garden Valley and East Boise County. For 2025, the county headline counted 228 single-family sales at a median of $584,959, including 48 newly built homes. The same annual report's area table counts 149 sales across the three mountain areas, and only 4 of them were new construction. Garden Valley accounted for 78 of those sales, at a $580,000 median, and only 3 were new builds.
So about 44 of the county's new homes sold in 2025 fall outside the three mountain areas, and the gap continued into this year. In the first quarter of 2026, the county counted 23 new-construction sales. The area table shows zero new builds in Horseshoe Bend, Garden Valley and East Boise County. Through October, the county had 83 new-construction sales for the year, against 36 over the same stretch of 2025.
The likeliest source of that new-home volume is Avimor, the planned community along State Highway 55 in the Eagle foothills. Boise County approved Avimor for up to 1,700 homes in April 2021, as BoiseDev reported. BoiseDev reported in 2025 that Avimor had built roughly 900 homes, about 50 of them in Boise County, all on the east side of Highway 55. Avimor's own site lists a phase called Boise County 1.
Those are suburban homes a short drive from Eagle, sold new by a developer. A cabin on the Middle Fork of the Payette sells as a resale, to a buyer who is weighing snow, septic and the drive up Highway 55. Both show up in the same Boise County median, but they are different products. When new construction rises from 36 sales to 83 in a year, the county median increasingly reflects what Avimor's new homes sell for and less what a Garden Valley cabin is worth.
Five sales make a median
Garden Valley's own figures have problems too. They come in small batches, and a small batch makes a jumpy median. Here is what Intermountain MLS printed for the Garden Valley area in the monthly reports for these months of 2025 and 2026:
| Month | Garden Valley sales | Median price |
|---|---|---|
| January 2025 | 4 | $550,000 |
| February 2025 | 5 | $420,000 |
| March 2025 | 4 | $665,500 |
| July 2025 | 5 | $768,338 |
| August 2025 | 8 | $489,000 |
| September 2025 | 6 | $491,500 |
| October 2025 | 10 | $640,950 |
| November 2025 | 7 | $710,000 |
| December 2025 | 7 | $435,000 |
| January 2026 | 0 | none |
| February 2026 | 3 | $425,000 |
| March 2026 | 9 | $565,000 |
| April 2026 | 7 | $550,000 |
From July to August 2025, the median fell almost $280,000. Then it climbed back above $700,000 by November and dropped to $435,000 in December. No real market for mountain homes moves that fast. When five homes sell, the median is just the price of the third one. If that third home is a riverfront log home one month and a small cabin on a timbered lot the next, the "market" appears to swing by hundreds of thousands of dollars while values on any given road haven't changed.
The full year gives a steadier picture. Garden Valley's 78 sales in 2025 carried a $580,000 median. The first quarter of 2026 brought 12 sales at a $537,500 median. Twelve sales is still a small sample. Treat it as a soft reading, not a 7% decline.
The valley-level view went away in May
Starting with the May 2026 report, the public monthly Boise County reports from Intermountain MLS dropped the page that broke sales out by area. Every report since then has shown only county totals plus a table of sales by price range. For anyone who wants Garden Valley's summer and fall 2026 numbers, the free public view now stops at April.
That is why October's $479,500 existing-home median needs care. It covers 12 sales across all of Boise County, and the county's days on market for the month was 95. Year to date through October, the county shows 239 sales at a $580,000 median, down 1.69% from the same period of 2025. That year-to-date figure lines up closely with Garden Valley's own $580,000 median for full-year 2025, and it is a more honest anchor than any single month.
Intermountain MLS also notes on every report that its figures come from agent-entered information that has not been verified. It also notes that existing and new-construction figures are calculated separately and may not add up to the total. For a market this small, that disclaimer matters.
Winter shrinks the sample further
Garden Valley averages about 71 inches of snow a season. The first snow usually arrives around mid-October and the snowpack generally melts by mid-May, according to the Boise County Comprehensive Plan. The months in the table above line up with that calendar. January 2026 recorded no Garden Valley sales at all, and February recorded three. Countywide, active listings went from 60 in January 2025 to 165 in July 2025.
In both of the last two winters, January through February brought only a few Garden Valley sales each month, so a buyer making an offer this winter will have few fresh closings to compare against. A winter showing also lets you see the drive to a cabin with snow on it. Our earlier post on what a Garden Valley listing price leaves out covers how road and plowing arrangements differ by community.
Not everything in the valley shuts down for winter. The outdoor geothermal pool at Terrace Lakes Resort stays open year-round at about 100 to 102 degrees. A buyer who books a winter showing weekend can see how the place feels in the season when it is quietest.
Pricing a Garden Valley cabin with this data
The county report is still useful, but mainly as a check on direction. A sound price for a Garden Valley home starts with sales from the same part of the valley, among homes with the same kind of access. A house at Terrace Lakes, a place in Southfork Landing, a home near Crouch and a parcel on an unplowed private road can all show up in one Garden Valley median. Each one competes against a different, smaller group of homes. With 78 sales across the valley in a full year, there may be only a handful of true comparables for any one property, and some will be a year old.
That changes how both buyers and sellers should read a number. A seller who prices off July 2025's $768,338 median is pricing off five houses. A buyer who reads October 2026's $479,500 existing-home figure as a 22% markdown is reading 12 sales spread across a county that runs from Horseshoe Bend to Lowman. The defensible numbers are the full-year median in the high $500,000s and the specific sales on your road or in your community. Both point to the same price only when the house is typical, and in Garden Valley few houses are.
For buyers still deciding whether the valley fits, our look at Garden Valley as a second-home market covers the lifestyle side, and current homes are on our Garden Valley homes for sale page.
If you own in Garden Valley and want to know what your home would sell for this winter, start with a free home valuation from Connie Boyce. We're glad to talk through how your home compares with recent Garden Valley sales rather than the county average.